According to BuddyTV.
Jensen is #1 and Jared is #3 (Jay should be #2).
And hey, JDM is #19. Are you nuts, people?
And this line made me laugh
There's a reason our readers are crazy about Jensen Ackles. Actually, if you ask them, there are about a million reasons. He's got more good looks and charm than he knows what to do with. Whoever puts a ring on this man will be a very lucky lady... but until that day comes, we know lots of die-hard Supernatural fans who will dream of being Mrs. Dean.
No worries, Jay got there first. And stop calling Padalecki a lucky lady, he's a lucky boy))